Peter Scully, the monster behind “Daisy’s Destruction”

Posted by

Among the most notorious and mysterious videos of the so-called “deep web”, “Daisy’s Destruction” is considered by many one of the most repugnant ever made, and for years it was described as a “snuff movie“. The man behind it is a controversial figure who never seemed to regret the horrors he committed, in many ways similar to those of Albert Fish.

📍 This story is on the Mystery Map: see where it happened →

Peter Scully

Peter Gerard Scully was born in Melbourne, Australia, on 13 January 1963. Little is known about his life, except that he lived with his wife and two children in Narre Warren, a suburb of the city, and that before fleeing to the Philippines he ran a fraud scheme worth millions, cheating investors out of a total of 2.68 million dollars. In 2009 he was investigated by the Australian authorities on 117 counts of fraud. In 2011 Scully fled Australia and took refuge in the Philippines. It was there that he began his “career” in a worldwide child abuse network.

He produced child abuse videos and sold them to customers in Germany, Britain and the United States through a website called “No Limits Fun”: a single video could cost up to 10,000 dollars.

His crimes came to light when two of his victims, cousins aged 9 and 12, managed to escape, freed by one of Scully’s accomplices. As soon as they were free, the girls went to the police, who opened an investigation. They said that a Filipino girl had approached them, offered them food and then taken them to the house of an “American”.

Carme Ann Alvarez (called Carmen in many articles), one of Scully’s partners and accomplices, had been recruited by him when she was little more than a child: after being abused by him, she became his “girlfriend”. Later, from prison, she gave her version of what happened to the two girls.

The abduction of the two cousins

Peter Scully

One day Scully asked her whether it was possible to adopt street children. She thought it was not, so she suggested that her sister could come and live with them. He refused: he wanted two street girls to “help”, and they had to be 9 and 12 years old.

So Carmen looked for two girls matching Scully’s request. It was not hard to find desperate, hungry children on the streets of Cagayan de Oro: two of them accepted her offer and followed her home.

She left them alone with Scully and came back two days later to find them in chains. The girls told her what the man had done to them, but when the police questioned her she said she had not known he was a “bad man”.

Five days of captivity

The account of Rosie, the 12-year-old, is chilling: Scully photographed and filmed the two girls and abused them.

One morning he forced the girls to dig two pits, telling them those would be their graves. Carmen took part too: while Scully was abusing Rosie, she covered the girl’s face with a pillow to stop her screaming. After five days of captivity, the two girls were freed by Carmen.

The case was led by Filipino agent Janet Francisco and Australian agent Paul Hopkins. The investigation uncovered horrifying details.

Sadly, the two cousins were not the monster’s only victims: there were younger ones too, some perhaps held for years. One video in particular stood out for its violence among those made by Scully: “Daisy’s Destruction”, made in 2012.

Daisy’s Destruction

Daisy's Destruction

Agent Hopkins explained that the video showed a Western man and Asian women abusing three girls: Liza, 12, Cindy, 11, and the youngest, Daisy, just 18 months old. There were other videos as well, and the police established that all the abuse had taken place in the Philippines and that at least 8 children were involved.

The man in the videos hid his face, but he could not disguise his Australian accent, and it was Agent Hopkins who noticed it. Thanks to that detail, an intense manhunt began.

The video has become almost an urban legend, and before it was actually found many descriptions of its content circulated, often inaccurate.

Some swore it was a snuff movie, others claimed to have seen little Daisy mutilated or killed. Although the content is truly horrifying, Daisy was not killed: she was rescued and today lives with her parents again.

The victims today

Agent Janet Francisco with little Daisy
Agent Janet Francisco with little Daisy

Thanks to the “Daisy’s Destruction” video, investigators identified fifteen places where the abuse had happened, all of which turned out to belong to one of Scully’s houses. Besides stopping the man, the police also tried to rescue the girls seen in the video.

Daisy and Liza are alive and were reunited with their parents, but for poor Cindy help came too late: Scully had strangled her and buried her in a shallow pit, dug by the girl herself, under his house.

Cindy’s death was also recorded by Scully himself.

Another of Scully’s partners was arrested too: Liezyl Margallo, then twenty, was considered his most loyal and ruthless accomplice. She denied it, claiming she did not know he had killed Cindy and had helped him only because she was forced to. She is one of the women seen in “Daisy’s Destruction”.

On 20 February 2015 Scully was finally arrested in Malaybalay, on the island of Mindanao, where investigators tracked him down with six arrest warrants against him.

The trial and the sentences

A few weeks after his arrest, in March 2015, Scully gave an interview to journalist Tara Brown for the Australian programme 60 Minutes, in which he said he was writing a diary in prison about the reasons for his crimes. The case caused such an outcry that some prosecutors called for the return of the death penalty, abolished in the Philippines in 2006.

In October 2015 a fire badly damaged the room where the computers and videos seized from Scully were kept, destroying important evidence. Arson was suspected, but it was never proven.

On 13 June 2018 the court of Cagayan de Oro, presided over by Judge Jose Escobido, sentenced Scully to life imprisonment for qualified human trafficking and five counts of rape, in the trial for the abduction of the two cousins.

Carme Ann Alvarez was also sentenced to life, and both were ordered to pay the victims 5 million pesos (almost 87,000 dollars) in damages.

In November 2022 came a second conviction: with a plea deal on another 60 charges, including child trafficking, child pornography and rape, Scully received another 129 years in prison. Liezyl Margallo (called Lovely in some articles) was sentenced to 126 years, while two other accomplices, Alexander Lao and Maria Dorothea Chia, got nine years each.

Finally, in 2025, the Supreme Court of the Philippines upheld the life sentences of Scully and Alvarez.

“Daisy’s Destruction” did not circulate only through Scully’s website: among those who spread it on the dark web was another Australian, Matthew David Graham, known as “Lux”, who ran a network of child abuse sites. He was arrested in 2014 and sentenced in 2016 to 15 years in prison.

Many thanks to Francesco, who helped write this article. Visit his very interesting site: 24framesite

🦋 Emadion lives through its readers. If this story kept you up at night, buy me a coffee: it helps me bring you the next nightmare.

☕ Support Emadion on Ko-fi

Sources

📍This story is on the Mystery MapSee where it happened and what other mysteries lurk nearby.View on the map →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *