Kerry Lyn Dalton, sentenced to death for a murder with no body

Posted by
In short
In June 1988, in a trailer in California, Irene Melanie May, 23, vanished for ever. According to the prosecution, Kerry Lyn Dalton and two accomplices tortured and killed her. Her body has never been found. In 1995 a court sentenced Dalton to death, and in 2019 the California Supreme Court upheld the sentence. She and her family still say she is innocent.

A murder with no body, no weapon, and witnesses who had been taking methamphetamine that night. And yet a death sentence. The case of Kerry Lyn Dalton is one of the most debated in California, and it still divides those who know it: torturer or innocent?

Help Emadion grow, click here.

Melanie

Irene Melanie May was 23. Her husband was in prison, and social services were following her three children. She used methamphetamine. On 25 June 1988 she lost her flat in Lakeside, near San Diego, and was moving her things into storage.

That day Kerry Lyn Dalton, 28, turned up too. She had once lived with Melanie and her husband. She was furious: she said that a lot of the furniture was hers, and she was looking for some jewellery. According to one witness, Melanie had sold some of Dalton’s belongings while Dalton was in jail.

The night in the trailer

That evening Melanie ended up in a car with Dalton, with Dalton’s boyfriend Mark Tompkins, with a friend, Sheryl Baker, and with a man known only as George. Melanie was afraid of Dalton, but she went anyway.

After hours of driving around they reached the trailer of an acquaintance, Joanne Fedor, in the Live Oak Springs park, in the mountains east of San Diego. They stayed up all night there, with drugs and arguments. Fedor heard Dalton call Melanie a “snitch” who had betrayed her husband. In the morning Dalton treated her like a servant. She made her wash the dishes, clean and make breakfast. Melanie told Fedor she was scared and asked her how she could get away.

At about 11:30 Fedor left with her children to visit her boyfriend in prison. Baker and Tompkins drove her. Dalton and Melanie stayed in the trailer.

Sheryl Baker’s account

What happened next comes to us mostly from Sheryl Baker. Years later she testified against Dalton in exchange for a lighter sentence.

According to Baker, when they came back in the afternoon they found someone sitting in the kitchen, covered by a sheet and tied to the chair. Dalton told her that Melanie had tried to escape and that they had to kill her. In the bathroom she had prepared some syringes filled, she said, with battery acid. She injected one into the young woman’s leg. Then she handed Baker a cast-iron frying pan and told her to hit her. In the end Tompkins stabbed her. They wrapped the body in a carpet and took it away.

A cellmate of Tompkins said that Tompkins had boasted of that “torture”. He said he had cut up the body on a nearby Indian reservation. According to Baker, Dalton later told her: “No body, no case.”

The investigation

That same evening Fedor called the sheriff. She said she had found a blood-soaked pillow, a screwdriver with hair on it and a bloody bar of soap. But the deputy found her confused and high on drugs. He saw nothing strange and left, and he never came back. The screwdriver, the knife and the pillow were lost.

Only in 1991 did investigators find small traces in the trailer that looked like blood. In 1992 police arrested Dalton, Tompkins and Baker. Tompkins pleaded guilty to first-degree murder, Baker to second-degree murder.

The sentence

Dalton’s trial began in San Diego in 1995. There was no body and there were no weapons. The main witnesses had been using methamphetamine for days. The defence kept stressing this: even the judge said in court that no body had ever been found.

The jury still found her guilty of torture murder and conspiracy, and chose the death penalty. On 23 May 1995 the court sentenced her to death.

In 2019 the California Supreme Court ruled on her appeal. It struck out one of the special circumstances, lying in wait, and the death sentence on the conspiracy count. But it upheld the death sentence for the murder. Since that year, executions in California have been on hold.

Torturer or innocent?

Kerry Lyn Dalton has always said she is innocent. Her sister wrote a book to defend her. Some people think the jury convicted her only on the word of drug users, who had everything to gain by accusing her.

For the judges, on the other hand, the testimonies were many and all pointed the same way. And then there is Melanie, whom nobody has seen since that June day in 1988.

I often think about her three children. In this whole story of trials and appeals, she is the one people talk about least. She does not even have a grave.

On Emadion, read also the story of Richard Speck.

Help Emadion grow, click here.

🦋 Emadion lives through its readers. If this story kept you up at night, buy me a coffee: it helps me bring you the next nightmare.

☕ Support Emadion on Ko-fi

Sources

9 comments

  1. Sounds like could been made up. She could be on run or others did it came up with a story . What does the boyfriend say happened? She may be guilty, but if not? God knows. What happened to innocent till proven guilty. I been in prison with people putting in my food and guards know in. Gang bang activity before during after my legs wouldn’t quit. People do get together and lie.

  2. She is guilty as hell a horrible drug crazed animal who is the most ruthless killer I have ever heard of …..what about her jailhouse calls? Why don’t anyone bring these up? I mean she in fact stated they murdered this woman ..

    The boyfriend got 25 yrs he had all the reason in the world too lie and save his life and he did not he told the truth and was slammed with a stiff sentence……this woman had a daughter tht loved her very much and it’s so sad so much symphony is shown too this maniac and none too the victim …..

    There is absolutely no doubt Kerry Dalton murdered May …

  3. This crazy physco needs to have her punishment fulfill. She is PURE EVIL. What about her victim,????. Kerry Dalton NEEDS TO DIE!!!@

    SHE IS A PURE MENACE TO SOCIETY.

    EVERYONE ELSE HAS BEEN PUNISHED. SO SHOULD SHE. THERE IS NO SYMPATHY FOR A EVIL BITCH LIKE HER!!!!

  4. Hang her
    Burn her
    The day after verdict
    Simple
    Slam dunk
    Injection is a mercy killing

    Especially baby molesters and killers
    Waterboard their asses and the hang them and burn them
    If we made justice harsh and swift crime and hurting and killing innocents, especially younger and older
    Well there’d be A LOT LESS CRIMES LIKE THESE

  5. There should have been more of an effort to search those Indian reservations where the body was supposedly disposed of. There would still be bones left. If the victim truly had her kneecaps smashed with a skillet, that would corroborate what the others were saying. I know it’s exceedingly difficult to obtain a search warrant for an Indian reservation, but still….no stone should be left uncovered.

  6. She killed May! She bragged about it and her co-defendant testified against her. Her boyfriend help depose of May body. Kerry is a lousy excuse of a human being. She been in and out of prison most of her life. Her saying she is innocent is the biggest lie. She trying to get on people sympathy. Kerry not innocent and needs to die. May daughter didn’t get to be with her mom. Kerry I hope they take you to that table and strap you down and stick that needle in your arm. Just like you did Melanie. So you will know how she felt. God have mercy on your soul.

  7. @Misty Wegener No. Multiple reasons
    -Firstly we are talking about a bunch of meth addicted, inbred hicks, they lack the intelligence to concoct a story to aide someone starting fresh elsewhere
    -Secondly they would also lack the brain cells to even be capable of thinking about banding together to pin blame on just one party, in an interrogation room they would fold like paper and only think of themselves, no way multiple, seperated individuals in this case had the wherewithal to weave a story of the same consistent lies to pass the buck to someone innocent
    -Thirdly kerry lyn herself admits to being present in the trailer while the torture was going on, for a prolonged period of time, even if she didn’t land the killing blow, she is still 100% cuplable in this case
    -Fourth why would they create a story involving specific graphic torture? No body was ever found, so if they all created a story about Irene running away to flee overbearing parents, just an example, then things would have played out differently. Circumstancial evidence and torture tools but no victim and no body, that would be a very different court case
    -Fifth, again bare in mind the statements from these scumbags were taken individually with them seperated ,specifically to avoid giving them the chance to talk amongst themselve and agree to stick to specific lies, so naturally the statements had conflicting reports and they tried to pass the blame to each other, but do you know what they all admitted to? That kerry lyn waste of oxygen dalton was present during the torture and she was the one who got the syringe filled with battery acid, which would’ve caused Irene a level of pain that none of us can imagine and a level of pain that the scumbags deserve to suffer daily until they die.

  8. Kerry lyn you know your guilty and deserve the death penalty. Everytime you are released from prison your out in society intimidating women and children. Even most men are afraid of you. This time you got caught. Your crying to the public saying your innocent is another way of you trying to manipulate the system. Your a bully and a evil bitch. God have mercy on your soul. Get right with God for he is the only one that can save your soul. They need to put you out of your misery and save tax payers money housing you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *